go here to buy my stock photography
------------------------------------

Alan Creech
born: 09-25-1966
where: Harlan, KY
lives: Lexington, KY
married: to Liz - 20 yrs
children: 4 - Katey, Meaghan, Conor, McKenzie


Custom Search


Subscribe in NewsGator Online
Add to Google




008

123

My Amazon.com Wish List

Alan Creech's Facebook profile

Subscribe to a feed of stuff on this page... Subscribe to my Flickr Photo feed
www.flickr.com
adcreech's photos More of adcreech's photos




> subscribe to my podcast


Mark Palmer Memorial Fund




my recent posts |::

music purchased > mark olson > review
interesting experience(s)
merton on legalism > 1
think too much
i reckon it's my birthday
wondering
useless
let's try this freelance design
chastisement > humility > transformation
exalt the cross

stuff |::

my family
abbey of gethsemani
new american bible
thomas merton center
apple computer
google
off-the-map
christian flights intl.
food network
trout unlimited
guinness

faith communities |::

vineyard central
matthew's house - ca
the landing place
ordinary community
saint patrick's
indy church
the well
communality
vineyard of montpelier
christ the king
diocese of lexington

blogs i read |::

aaron klinefelter
aimee milburn
amy welborn
andrew jones
asbury seminary
beth keck
boar's head tavern
brother maynard
bryan sherwood
chris marshall
dan phillips
darren rowse
david finch
debi warford
d.g. hollums
eric keck
eric kieb
glenn johnson
heather hofacre
jason evans
jeana clark
jeff prosser
john michael talbot
jordon cooper
kevin rains
kyle potter
laura ogle
lisa ponchak
liz creech
malcolm hawker
michael spencer
mike & amber bishop
mike noakes
palmer
paul fromont
pete matthews
peter white
roger bourland
scot mcknight
steve bogner
steve thompson
tom ponchak
will humes

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivs 2.5 License.


October 03, 2007 >> 1:01 PM
merton on legalism > 2

It took me long enough - here's the next post in the "Merton on Legalism" series. I know you've been waiting with baited breath, or you just went out and bought the book (Disputed Questions). Off we go...
Legalism is not synomymous with conservatism or traditionalism. It can equally well be found in those social-minded Christians who, by their contact with Communism in the movement for social justice, have unwittingly contracted a spirit of totalitarian narrowness and intolerance. The temptation to legalism arises precisely when the apparent holiness of a cause and even its manifest rightness blings us to the holiness of individuals and persons. We tend to forget that charity comes first and is the only Christian "cause" that has the right to precedence over every other.

Legalism in practice makes law and discipline more important than love itself. For the legalist, law is more worthy of love than the persons for whose benefit the law was instituted. Discipline is more important than the good of souls to whom discipline is given, not as an end in itself but as a means to their growth in Christ.

The authoritarian Christian does not love his brother so much as he loves the cause or the policy which he wants his brother to follow. For him, love of the brother consists, not in helping his brother to grow and mature in love as an individual person loved by Christ, but in making him "toe the line" and fulfill exterior obligations, without any regard for the interior need of his soul for love, understanding and communion. All too often, for the legalist, love of his brother means punishing his brother, in order to force him to become "what he ought to be." Then, when this is achieved, perhaps the brother can be loved. But until then he is not really "worthy of love."

This is in reality a fatal perversion of the Christian spirit. Such "love" is the enemy of the Cross if Christ because it flatly contradicts the teaching and the mercy of Christ. It treats man as if he were made for the sabbath. It loves concepts and despises persons. It is the kind of love that says corban (see Mark 7:9-13) and makes void the commandment of God "in order to keep the traditions of men" (ibid.). –(bolding mine) Thomas Merton; Disputed Questions
Wow. I'm not sure you can say it any stronger than that. The "enemy of the Cross of Christ" - yes sir. That will get some attention. And think, ecclesio-culturally, of the Catholicism of his day - some attention indeed. Of course big Tom often got negative attention from his superiors and from "the censors" of his Order and the Church authorities. Not all negative, certainly - lots of positive too. Anyway, he said some strong things and pretty generally came off on the "non legalistic" side of things in his day.

I thought it fair of him to point out, in the beginning there, that this kind of attitude is found also in "liberal" circles in the Church. I'm sure this kind of thing is much more common now than in 1960 even. I see it quite a bit in certain circles - the whole social justice way of thinking now coupled with the unChristianization of anyone who doesn't recycle enough or reduce their carbon footprint. You have heard that God looks way down on such sinners, right? OK, now you know. It's on all sides folks.

Historically, and in my experience, I have been the person and seen the people who act and think this way more from the other side of the legalistic fence. It is most commonly associated with a kind of Pharisaical way of thought and being. This, I hate. It's so destructive of a healthy spiritual life, I would have a hard time describing it. I have contributed to such destructive attitudes being built into people in the past and I'm ashamed of it. I have had it put into me and I'm a little angry that it ever was. It damaged me and my ability to freely and openly relate to God as a loving Father. That's not the only diet I ever got but it was part of the mix (and not just in Catholic circles either - perhaps even more in some others).

Merton was a Catholic - a priest even - a MONK even! He said things like this, wrote them. I'm sure some people would find that amazing, that he would say something terribly negative about "keeping the traditions of men" - a charge thrown at the Catholic Church often by some in other Christian traditions. Now, Merton knew well, as do I, that the charge is possibly true at times, especially in certain areas of Catholicism. It's had a lot of time to build up thing upon thing, spreading out from the core. That's just an aside, a personal reflection. I'm not writing just about Catholics or the Catholic Church. The phenomenon of legalism is certainly not cornered in the Catholic market. It has its inherent pitfalls, but it's an equal opportunity disease.

Sure, there is Truth. There are truths which are simply true. And truth sets us free, not falsehood. We must know this. But all rules or discipline or even laws are not all about truth and freedom in Christ. Many are about fear and control and a wrong-headed way to get people to "be good so they get to heaven." In all this, somehow, it was seemingly forgotten, the very center of our Christian faith - the Love and Mercy of God our Father which leads, as He embraces us, to our transformation into beautiful new children. We forgot, along the way, about that part. We got selfish - all about ME going to Heaven. Put your blinders on and power through this life to get to the other side! I could go on and on with this but hopefully you get the point. We must awake from our long slumber and become, once again, aware of the core, the point - our relational union with God leading to our transformation. And when we grow in this union, we naturally begin reflecting the Nature of our Father, and that is Love. Take care. Allow yourself to be awakened. God, give us all Grace to know well.

technorati tags > , ,

Labels: , , ,

::: ::: permalink ::: e-mail me :::

 

 

 


daily prayer |::

ordinary time
psalter week 1
LOTH book 4

> morning - lauds
> evening - vespers
> night - compline

> e-breviary.com

lectionary readings |::

> today



stations of
the cross
meditation
here


three quotes |::

"Then, if we cannot as yet think alike in all things, at least we may love alike. Herein we cannot possibly do amiss."
John Wesley

"Keep your eyes on the crucifix, for Jesus without the cross is a man without a mission, and the cross without Jesus is a burden without a reliever."
Fulton J. Sheen

"...I am deeply convinced that the Christian leader of the future is called to be completely irrelevant and to stand in this world with nothing to offer but his or her own vulnerable self."
Henri Nouwen



my blog post labels |::

blogging
catholic
church
community
cooking
emerging church
family
leadership
liturgy
merton
monasticism
personal
reversion
spiritual formation
theology

zines |::

next wave
the ooze
ginkworld
house2house
ship of fools
christianity today
regenerator

archives |::



august 03
july 03
june 03
may 03
april 03
march 03
february 03
january 03
december 02
november 02
october 02
september 02
august 02
july 02
june 02
may 02
march/april 02
february 02