go here to buy my stock photography
------------------------------------

Alan Creech
born: 09-25-1966
where: Harlan, KY
lives: Lexington, KY
married: to Liz - 19 yrs
children: 4 - Katey, Meaghan, Conor, McKenzie


Subscribe in NewsGator Online
Add to Google

Subscribe in Rojo

123

My Amazon.com Wish List

Alan Creech's Facebook profile


Subscribe to a feed of stuff on this page... Subscribe to my Flickr Photo feed
www.flickr.com
adcreech's photos More of adcreech's photos




> subscribe to my podcast


Mark Palmer Memorial Fund





my recent posts |::

train up a child
that darned weather
a tool for meditation
links > thoughts
time for a nap
reaction to responses
the road back in > a catholic update
the pond > fish count
motu proprio > summorum pontificum
confucius say...

stuff |::

my family
abbey of gethsemani
new american bible
thomas merton center
apple computer
google
off-the-map
christian flights intl.
food network
trout unlimited
guinness

faith communities |::

vine & branches
vineyard central
matthew's house - ca
matthew's house - fl
the landing place
ordinary community
saint patrick's
indy church
the well
communality
vineyard of montpelier

blogs i read |::

aaron klinefelter
aimee milburn
amy welborn
andrew jones
asbury seminary
beth keck
bill bean
boar's head tavern
brian phillips
brother maynard
bryan sherwood
chris marshall
dan phillips
darren rowse
david finch
debi warford
dwight longenecker
eric keck
eric kieb
glenn johnson
heather hofacre
jason evans
jeana clark
jeff prosser
jim tucker
john michael talbot
jordon cooper
kelli shearron
kevin rains
kyle potter
laura ogle
lisa ponchak
liz creech
malcolm hawker
michael spencer
mike & amber bishop
mike noakes
palmer
paul fromont
pete matthews
peter white
roger bourland
scot mcknight
steve bogner
steve thompson
tom ponchak
will humes

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivs 2.5 License.


July 29, 2007 >> 11:38 AM
zeal without wisdom

A few days ago I got an e-mail from my friend Mike Bishop (hope you don't mind, dude, but you're busted out), asking me about a Merton quote he had seen in a Eugene Peterson book. He wanted to get my take on it. He already had most of what thought there, and I added my 4.5 cents worth in a reply, which I'm turning into a blog post here. How's that for recycling. Maybe we should call that "green blogging." ha! I've edited this e-mail deal a bit so it will fit better in a blog arena. OK, here it begins...
I've been reading a wonderful little book by EuPete called "The Jesus Way" and he has a quote from Senor Merton from "Seasons of Celebration"... Here it is (from page 18):

"We must be on guard against a kind of blind and immature zeal - the zeal of the enthusiast or the zealot - which represents precisely a frantic compensation for the deeply personal qualities which are lacking to us. The zealot is man who "loses himself" in his cause in such a way that he can no longer "find himself" at all. Yet paradoxically this "loss" of himself is not the salutary self-forgetfulness commanded by Christ. It is rather an immersion in his own willfulness conceived of as the will of an abstract, non-personal force: the force of a project or program."

Peterson was using the quote in discussing the ruin caused by religious zealotry, specifically violence. However, it seems to me that Merton might be speaking of something more subtle, of a violence done by - in some cases - our desire to do good that turns into a self-perpetuating monster. That monster might even take the form of something benign like a soup kitchen or a church plant, if done while being lost in a cause or caught by the wave of social momentum (which, by the way, is how I think most North American churches grow).
My response: I think you're very right, actually. It sounds like the kind of "zealotry" he's probably talking about is the kind that you find INside the monastery, with which he would have been extremely familiar, even from within himself. He talks about things like this often in other places, not necessarily in those words, but definitely the same concept. He oversaw the spiritual formation of quite a number of younger monks while he was there, not to mention unofficially being a spiritual director to so many people outside the walls of the place. The kind of thing you're describing is very much what he warns against many times in other writings.

It's that thing we see so often in charismatic circles (we're both familiar with that for sure) - the "God told me's" - Young monks in Cistercian monasteries get that same ailment. They "hear" things all the time. They get excited about having heard something and they immaturely run with something they do not properly understand, that they haven't grown enough to get hold of yet. This happens constantly with very sincere young Christians. Unfortunately, it happens with "older" Christians too, those who should "by this time be teachers." We have, in certain circles, forgotten how to spiritually parent people, how to help form them into new Creatures. I'm sure old Dallas could chime in on that for a while.

I just started re-reading a Merton book this week, his last, published recently post-mortem, called The Inner Experience. It's thoughts about contemplation and the contemplative life. I'll give you a short quote which I think ties in well with what you're talking about...

Well, first he goes on talking about how we often are not who we think we are. We have illusions about ourselves that we tell to ourselves and many times we can't even recognize these illusions. So when we say "I" this, want that or whatever, we're not even talking about our real selves but some externally constructed partial self that needs to be torn down in order for us to, essentially, in my words, get real and be real to ourselves and to God. OK, now the quote...
"If such and 'I' one day hears about 'contemplation,' he will perhaps se himself to 'become a contemplative.' That is, he will wish to admire, in himself, something called contemplation. And in order to see it, he will reflect on his alienated self. He will make contemplative faces at himself like a child in front of a mirror. He will cultivate the contemplative look that seems appropriate to him and that he likes to see in himself. And the fact that his busy narcissism is turned within and feeds upon itself in stillness and secret love will make him believe that -- his experience of himself is an experience with God."
I think that is very parallel to what you're talking about. And it's not that this proverbial guy is even aware that he's doing anything bad, he's just doing it. But it is bad. What he's learning and what he's teaching himself in this exercise there is illusory, not real, and certainly not God. So, he is stunted and yet, believes that he is growing. Very dangerous stuff.

My response to my response:
Very dangerous indeed. It may well be one of the most dangerous things we encounter in the process of our spiritual development, and what screams out for good spiritual direction. I mean, when one of us somehow gets the idea that we are more mature than we actually are. This happens a LOT I think, especially when Christians are basically left alone to guide their own spiritual development. Do I have to pull out the obvious analogy of kids raising themselves? Please. You can't live on whipped cream forever, or popsicles - you get the point. When we think we have attained to a certain level and we are perhaps actually 15 "levels" down yet, we can cause ourselves, and those around us, a lot of trouble. Sorry, these things come fast and furious to mind, but you could hurt yourself pretty badly if you try to climb El Capitan and you're not ready for that.

We have woefully left behind the concept that someone who is young in the faith needs an older, more mature, wiser guide to help them along to maturity. This is left for monks and priests and ministers. They're the ones who are really serious about the whole religious thing anyway. God, help us remember.

technorati tags > , , ,

Labels: ,

::: ::: permalink ::: e-mail me :::  

 

 

 


daily prayer |::

ordinary time
psalter week 3
LOTH book iv

> morning - lauds
> evening - vespers
> night - compline

lectionary readings |::

> today



stations of
the cross
meditation
here


three quotes |::

"Then, if we cannot as yet think alike in all things, at least we may love alike. Herein we cannot possibly do amiss."
John Wesley

"Keep your eyes on the crucifix, for Jesus without the cross is a man without a mission, and the cross without Jesus is a burden without a reliever."
Fulton J. Sheen

"...I am deeply convinced that the Christian leader of the future is called to be completely irrelevant and to stand in this world with nothing to offer but his or her own vulnerable self."
Henri Nouwen



my blog post labels |::

blogging
catholic
church
community
cooking
emerging church
family
leadership
liturgy
merton
monasticism
spiritual formation
theology

zines |::

next wave
the ooze
ginkworld
house2house
ship of fools
christianity today
regenerator

archives |::



august 03
july 03
june 03
may 03
april 03
march 03
february 03
january 03
december 02
november 02
october 02
september 02
august 02
july 02
june 02
may 02
march/april 02
february 02